Catalyst »HomeArchivesAbout Quick Story »



Allergies: The mistaken invaders

OTTAWA — An army is called to protect the citizens of a small town, which is threatened by powerful invaders. The soldiers need to be quick on their feet, but they are not trained to distinguish friend from foe. So whenever the soldiers see a large group approaching, they attack regardless of whether or not its an invading force or a needed ally. The result is friendly fire.


In one instance, the army attacks a convoy carrying bread and wheat, which is in dangerously short supply.  The firefight severely damages the town, and the convoy can’t deliver the food.  The allied commander decides it's too dangerous to send food to the town and cuts off all shipments. Now the town is suffering, deprived of vital nutrients and resentful of the local army.

Food allergies can work the same way. According to a Canadian Medical Association study, more t han 150,000 Canadians suffer from the life-threatening allergy known as anaphylaxis.

In this condition, the body’s immune system overreacts to otherwise common substances found in peanuts, tree nuts, milk products, shellfish and bee venom. Typically our immune system protects us from viruses and bacteria that would hurt us but in cases where anaphylaxis has been diagnosed, the immune system perceives even garden-variety substances as a threat.

Fighting the invader

The body’s immune system will immediately react to an allergen outwardly with  swelling of the face, lips and tongue, hives, vomiting, and diarrhea.

Peanut butter and jelly
The peanut butter and jelly sandwich, a longtime staple of kids' lunchboxes, is off-limits for those with peanut allergies.

Internally, the body is rapidly going into shock as the airway swells. Without proper treatment, a person can quickly lapse into a coma and die.

Here’s what happens.

“The airways clamp down and they fill with mucous,” explains Dr. Peter Vardas, a physician at St. Michael’s Hospital in Toronto. “It becomes very difficult to breathe and they will also experience a drop in blood pressure to the point where there may not be enough oxygen being delivered to the tissues. They may have problems with heart rhythm and the blood vessels in the heart might constrict and lead to inadequate oxygen delivery to the heart.”

Anaphylaxis has become a particular problem for the education system, as schools struggle to cope with students for whom even a trace of an offending substance can lead to a life-threatening situation.

Many schools have banned peanuts and nut-based products outright, arguing that the welfare of the allergic students must be protected. Some parents of non-allergic students have subsequently complained about these policies, arguing that it is now very difficult to know what foods are affordable and safe for their children’s lunch bag. 

Even so, when students with severe food allergies move from high school to an open world, they are again at risk. Three areas of scientific research are ongoing to find a solution: Breeding peanuts that are missing the allergy-causing proteins, experimenting with drugs that may lessen allergic reactions, and looking for alternatives to peanut and other nut butters.

The army's new weapons

It is the first of these avenues that primarily intrigues scientists.  Isolate the protein responsible for the allergic reaction and disarm it.  Tests have shown that most people with food allergies have an antibody known as immunoglobulin E in their bloodstream. This immunoglobulin seems to fixate on certain types of proteins, rather like a sniper trained to look for specific enemies. The problem is that the immunoglobulin appears to get “confused” and sense a threat when in fact none exists. Once it has become sensitized to a certain protein, it is much more likely to react when it comes into contact with the same protein again and trigger the allergic reaction that can be so devastating.

Peanuts
Scientists are working to modify the genetic structure of peanuts so that they no longer pose a danger to anaphylactics.

The U.S. Department of Agriculture is exploring the possibility of breeding a hypoallergenic peanut. Scientists have screened approximately 300 varieties of peanuts to look for one that does not contain the specific type of protein most often implicated in allergic reactions. So far, they have identified the NC 4 peanut as one that lacks the protein vicilin Ara h 2 .

“Removing the allergens Ara h 1 and h 2 would reduce the numbers of people affected by peanut allergies by up to 50 per cent,” says Soheila Maleki, the lead chemist in the development of the NC 4 peanut.

Of course, this is not a blanket solution. There are approximately 14,000 different types of peanuts, and finding one without the two offending allergens is “like finding a needle in a haystack,” Dr. Maleki says. Therefore, other researchers are attempting to use genetic engineering techniques to switch off the allergens that peanuts contain. Unfortunately for concerned students and their parents, the need to send only these “safe” peanuts to school would still exist.

Research into genetically-modified peanuts and other forms of allergy prevention is in its infancy, there is much yet to be learned. Will nut butters made from genetically-modified peanuts cost more than conventional peanut butters? Will there be a substantial difference in taste? Will consumers balk at the idea of a genetically-modified peanut as they traditionally have for other GM foods? All of these questions remain to be answered.

Nevertheless, progress is being made. And for many sufferers of peanut and other life-threatening allergies, this can only mean good news.

Related Links

Anaphylaxis Canada

Mayo Clinic: Food Allergies

Sabrina's Law: Prevention and Management of Life-Threatening Food Allergies

Sabrina's Law

In 2003 Sabrina Shannon, a 14-year-old girl in Pembroke, Ontario died of an allergic reaction after eating French fries contaminated with milk products. Tongs used to serve Sabrina’s fries had  come into contact with cheese curds used to make poutine. Cross contamination is a constant threat.

Sabrina’s death set in motion a lobby for new legislation in Ontario. Bill 3, an Act to protect anaphylactic pupils, passed in 2005.

Now known as Sabrina’s Law, the Bill “requires school boards to have policies that include training for school staff on dealing with life-threatening allergies on a regular basis; creating individual plans for pupils who have an anaphylaxis allergy; and having emergency procedures in place for anaphylactic pupils,” according to a release from the Ontario government.

Source: Sabrina's Law: Prevention and Management of Life-Threatening Food Allergies

 

Fighting allergies: Other methods

Two common methods of fighting allergies are allergy shots and alternative products to replace the offending substance.

An allergy shot contains a very small amount of the substance that one is allergic to (called an allergen). Allergy shots help one's body fight the allergen. When someone gets shots of the allergen, their body makes antibodies to the allergen. The next time the person has contact with the allergen, these antibodies help to block its effect. As the antibodies block the way a person's body reacts to the allergen, the person's allergy symptoms become less severe. After many allergy shots, they might start to get relief from their symptoms, which may last for a long time.

For those allergic to peanuts and peanut butter, there is an alternative. Peabutter uses vegetable oil, dried peas and sugar in a spread that roughly approximates the texture and taste of peanut butter. Various types of almond butter are also available. These products must be manufactured in a peanut-free factory.

Source: The American Academy of Family Physicians; Wikipedia

 



© Carleton University School of Journalism and Communication